Read our full instrumented test of the volkswagen golf r, an allwheeldrive turbocharged hoot of a hatchback. Steve sutcliffe and david vivian lock horns and you can have your say. Maybe the issue is when comparing the dsg stronic to the manual audi s4 or gti or golf r etc, since those vw group manuals are all a bit on the clunky side, with long throws. The parking prize, however, must go to the dsg volkswagen golf gti. Mar 01, 2018 but lets say youre set on vw s golf r should you stick to the manual or get the dsg instead. I wanted a manual and wasnt at all interested in dsg. Ive seen a van which ticks all the boxes for me, however its dsg and i wasnt overly impressed with it when i test drove it. Vw golf r dsg v manual video 12 may 2010 they main problem with the manual, in this rather pointless 060 exercise, is that second gear doesnt take you to 60, which is a bit odd.
Is the vw golf r better with a manual or automatic gearbox. Get the results, specs, and photos at car and driver. Volkswagen ags dsgs direct shift gearbox could be found in the mk5, mk6, and mk7 golf, gti. Looking in to get a 2015 gti, but i am not sure if i should go with dsg or manual. Top gear ran a dsgequipped golf r as a muchloved longterm test car. In fact i go as far as saying more than half the golf r cars local to me in my price range were dsg. Yuri and jakub, from the straight pipes, pitted the 2018 golf r manual against the 2018 golf r dsg, which is our automatic transmission, against each other. It uses a 2liter turbocharged engine 292 hp, 280 lbft which sends its resources to all four wheels through the 4motion allwheeldrive setup. Manual mode on dsg is way more fun and engaging than true manual. With the majority of manufacturers reporting similar sales splits in favour of paddleequipped models. I was in the same boat a few years ago when buying a mk5 golf gti. As you can see, the dsg is currently reserved for models that are more performancefocused, like the hot hatches and the v6 passat. The biggest thing i noticed w the dsg that i missed was the ability to cruise w the clutch in when coming up to a stop or something. A sixspeed manual transmission is standard with the golf r.
I am wondering if anyone regrets getting the automatic version of a golf r instead of the manual. I tested both the manual and dsg prior to purchasing my mk7 r and found the wife found the dsg to be a little more suited to. Vehicles that are refined and smoothdriving are getting the new eightspeed automatic, such as is found in the 2018 volkswagen tiguan or the upcoming 2019 volkswagen arteon. Whilst i appreciate the dsg box is not quite the same thing as that, ive always preferred manual boxes unless having to do lots of town driving and the golf r manual. The 2018 volkswagen golf r has gotten a refresh before an allnew generation next year. Considering a subaru wrx sti, ford focus rs, honda civic type r, mercedesamg gla45. Maybe i just need to give it more time and perhaps live with it for a while before. Dec 23, 2016 vw claims the new r launches to 62mph in 4. Honda has the civic type r, fords focus rs is worth having a look at, then theres the renault megane r. Purists will be pleased with the standard sixspeed manual transmission, but. The golf r gives vw hothatchback parity with the ford focus rs and a formidable weapon against the. Vw golf r vs audi s3 manual vs automatic drag race what difference does the gearbox make.
But lets come back to the main culprit here, the vw golf r. Until the vw golf mk8 gets over 300bhp and fourwheel drive, its quite simply the fastest vw golf. A performance monitor lets you check vitals on your touchscreen. Mar 16, 2018 read our full instrumented test of the volkswagen golf r, an allwheeldrive turbocharged hoot of a hatchback. They examined the vw golf r mannequin with guide and dsg gearbox. Manual vs dsg in a golf r vw gti mkvi forum vw golf r. In this video i give you 5 reasons why a dual clutch transmission is better than a standard. There is no way in the world would i pick the manual golf r over the dsg equipped one. Manual vs dsg hi all, looking to get my first golf specifically r or gti, ive always driven manuals and love the ability to control the car but clearly the appeal of the dsg has got me curious.
Everyone says dsg is very good, but i guess i will have to test drive gti with dsg and see how i like it. Plenty of performance, looks just right and its still a golf so its. Got the option on a cheap golf r with the manual box. I live in the seattle area, and traffic here is a nightmare most of the time. Alternatively, watch the vw golf r dsg versus manual video here. Or are they glad they picked the automatic over the manual. The times in this video were taken on a slight incline and they vary from other sources as this is.
Dsg or manual vw golf r mk7 chat vwroc vw r owners club. See, the smart thinking driver always knew that though the rbadged golfs had more. Jan 12, 2018 in this video i give you 5 reasons why a dual clutch transmission is better than a standard. The vw golf r with dsg and ford focus rs test their top speed. I love driving manual cars, however im left with nasty knee pain whenever i drive my boyfriends wrx in traffic. Although vw s dsg dualclutch automated manual is a good, reasonably sporty automatic, it is still an. Having driven a manual for 30 years i still occasionally reach for the clutch pedal out of instinct. The golf r is the understated and underrated antithesis of its redhot.
A week ago i would of said manual all the way, but i bought a rocco gt with the dsg box on monday and its amazing. Its the instant gear changes that gets me and the noise when shifting up the box. So does the fastshifting dualclutch transmission allow the golf r to outrun the focus rs in a straight line from 0 to 100 kmh and then from 0 to 250 kmh. A sixspeed manual transmission dispenses torque via volkswagens 4motion. The formula changed little from the previous golf r. Id been fairly set on dsg if i did get one, but the cost would be significantly higher. This mannequin is basically nice, however this can be a nice take a look at and a transparent reply to the query who select transmission on this mannequin. I test drove a manual, and although it felt nice, i still went with the dsg.
Thestraightpipes staff gave a transparent reply to this query. Considering a subaru wrx sti, ford focus rs, honda civic type r, mercedesamg. The vw figure is a better than average one for its. To our surprise our new lapiz blue vw golf r demo is a manual, not dsg as. But then i drove a golf r dsg and manual back to back. Dsg is def quicker and can be fun and better than mt in certain scenarios, but at the end of the day it wont keep you as involved with driving the car as a manual transmission will. Mkvi gti dsg vs manual exhaust sound quick clip showing the exhaust sound from two my11 gtis. However, you can spec a dualclutch dsg gearbox, adding an extra gear in the process.
Learn more about bramgate volkswagen and your ontario community. The dsg adds little to the dynamics and plenty to the final price, and spoils those classleading co2 figures. Vw golf r vs audi s3 manual vs automatic drag race what. They shift up and down on there own, regardless of what the driver wants, even in manual mode. David zalstein and tony crawford tackle the question using one of the worlds best and most popular hothatches, the volkswagen golf gti. Automotive editor james riswick advocates sticking with the manual. The 2019 vw golf r is trackinspired with a turbocharged engine, while also providing an equally sophisticated ride. Anyone regret buying a golf r in an auto vs manual. Read our full instrumented test of the volkswagen golf r. The vw golf r is good but is it better with a dsg or manual gearbox. Considering a subaru wrx sti, ford focus rs, honda civic type r, mercedes amg. The edmunds longterm 2015 volkswagen golf gti comes with the optional dsg automatic.
1008 1314 313 242 424 614 645 995 1168 241 58 489 878 816 1524 1341 900 1458 1627 125 774 1410 1656 439 1106 1198 1160 848 476 505 457 517 622 261 862 962 584